[SpookyZalost]

ok so question, given the changes in the last 3 years since this was last looked at, do you guys still agree that "Youtubing" is an art?

Most of them, no. Some of them, absolutely. 

Depends on the video and the actual effort that went into it. Was it creative? 

ok where do you think the line is drawn?

Let's plays could be argued to straddle that line for example depending on, like you said, effort and if it's creative or not.

but at the same time I'd say animations and such fall firmly into the art catagory.