+- Makestation (https://makestation.net)
+-- Forum: Creative Arts (https://makestation.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=54)
+--- Forum: Photography & Graphics (https://makestation.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+--- Thread: Is online video making a form of art? (/showthread.php?tid=637)
Is online video making a form of art? - Warwick - September 22nd, 2013
YouTube has exploded in the past few years with thousands of content creators who make all sort of creative videos that sometimes tend to reach hollywood-quality...
Do you consider online video making a form of art? Can it be included in the same branch as cinematography?
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - Darth-Apple - September 22nd, 2013
I would agree, the market has definitely expanded significantly over the past few years. I've considered going into the field as well, but the lack of good equipment/software and time has made it difficult for me. I'd like to get a decent PC at some point and give it a shot again sometime.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - AtlasWest - September 22nd, 2013
There's no doubt that videos on youtube are a form of art. But I've heard from people that love traditional film photography that digital photography shouldn't be considered art because they're just binary numbers. How are binary numbers art?
Of course, art to me is an experience that requires us to connect using our senses, so whether the palette contains blob of paint or a bunch of 0's and 1's, whether music is coming off of a vinyl or an iPod, it's all art to me. So to me, digital videos on youtube is definitely art, and I think it's been a great tool in empowering people all around the world.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - Darth-Apple - September 22nd, 2013
(September 22nd, 2013 at 7:56 PM)AtlasWest Wrote: There's no doubt that videos on youtube are a form of art. But I've heard from people that love traditional film photography that digital photography shouldn't be considered art because they're just binary numbers. How are binary numbers art?
Of course, art to me is an experience that requires us to connect using our senses, so whether the palette contains blob of paint or a bunch of 0's and 1's, whether music is coming off of a vinyl or an iPod, it's all art to me. So to me, digital videos on youtube is definitely art, and I think it's been a great tool in empowering people all around the world.
Well said. I do think that non-digital forms of art are always very valuable, but there is no reason that digital art does not qualify as art. Digital art is probably going to become increasingly popular as technology continues to advance in any case.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - forthwall - September 23rd, 2013
Its as artistic as any movie or tv show, so yes very much of an art. Even YTP.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - nolvorite - October 18th, 2013
It's just like running a TV Show, just a slightly different audience.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - Darth-Apple - October 18th, 2013
I actually very much prefer the youtube channel atmosphere over the television atmosphere. Most channel owners have much more control over their content, so it always feels more original.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - zingaling - April 24th, 2014
I don't see why it wouldn't be.
Whether any particular video is itself *good* art might be open to question, and of course not every video is intended as art. But the same could be said of photography, digital or otherwise.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - RuthB - April 25th, 2014
Yes, I am sure online video can be an art. As in all art there will always be amateur attempts as well as truly creative works.
A simple talking head, or a practical demonstration is not going to viewed as a form of art. Creative use of video will shows different viewpoints or have a narrative element in what is filmed. It will use different types of software or animation to produce something that is amazing to view and forms a memorable impression.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - bench91 - April 25th, 2014
l definitely think that making online video's is a art form, l would love to be able to make a online video but l would not know where to start, l know there is a lot of information online on how to make a online video and l might start looking it up in the future.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - Darth-Apple - April 26th, 2014
It takes creativity to create something unique, which is major challenge for that sort of a niche.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - SpookyZalost - May 30th, 2017
ok so question, given the changes in the last 3 years since this was last looked at, do you guys still agree that "Youtubing" is an art?
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - Guardian - May 30th, 2017
(May 30th, 2017 at 5:02 AM)SpookyZalost Wrote: ok so question, given the changes in the last 3 years since this was last looked at, do you guys still agree that "Youtubing" is an art?
Most of them, no. Some of them, absolutely.
Depends on the video and the actual effort that went into it. Was it creative?
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - SpookyZalost - May 31st, 2017
(May 30th, 2017 at 11:00 PM)Guardian Wrote:(May 30th, 2017 at 5:02 AM)SpookyZalost Wrote: ok so question, given the changes in the last 3 years since this was last looked at, do you guys still agree that "Youtubing" is an art?
Most of them, no. Some of them, absolutely.
Depends on the video and the actual effort that went into it. Was it creative?
ok where do you think the line is drawn?
Let's plays could be argued to straddle that line for example depending on, like you said, effort and if it's creative or not.
but at the same time I'd say animations and such fall firmly into the art catagory.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - Guardian - June 4th, 2017
(May 31st, 2017 at 3:55 AM)SpookyZalost Wrote: ok where do you think the line is drawn?
Let's plays could be argued to straddle that line for example depending on, like you said, effort and if it's creative or not.
but at the same time I'd say animations and such fall firmly into the art catagory.
I would say so. But, just like any art, it really is all up to the viewer.
Some paintings would not be called art to some. It really all depends.
RE: Is online video making a form of art? - SpookyZalost - July 7th, 2017
This is true, though I personally think Mondrian's are cool regardless
